Commentary: Conflict in Karabakh Threatens Peace within the Whole Region | Comments from DW Reviewers and Guest Contributors | DW

Large-scale navy operations resumed in Nagorno-Karabakh. Both sides of the battle – Azerbaijan and Armenia – report tons of of deaths from the other aspect, each discuss a “counteroffensive”. There have been allegedly no attackers, however individuals are dying. If the worldwide group fails to attain a ceasefire, this armed battle – there’s a actual hazard of escalating right into a full-fledged struggle – might turn into one of many bloodiest within the post-Soviet area in recent times. In addition, neighboring international locations, together with Turkey and Russia, could also be drawn into it.

Fighting in Karabakh: a brand new take a look at of power or a struggle?

In July 2020, there have been already intense battles between Azerbaijan and Armenia, throughout which individuals died. True, this was not on the dividing line, which is now the de facto border of the self-proclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (NKR) with Azerbaijan, however straight on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border. Then it appears to have been a take a look at of power. Therefore, the primary query in the mean time is whether or not that is the case this time too? It is obvious that the present combating is essentially the most intense within the area for the reason that 1994 ceasefire. However, is it concerning the starting of a brand new Karabakh struggle?

Judging by the outcomes of the primary day of the battle, if, after all, the statements of the belligerents could be trusted in any respect, there isn’t a readability. Not a single main settlement has but been occupied because of the Azerbaijani assault (the authorities in Baku declare that this was a counteroffensive “to suppress the fight exercise of the Armenian armed forces and make sure the security of the civilian inhabitants”).

The events argue about management over the border mountain heights and declare tons of of deaths within the enemy ranks. The Armenian Defense Ministry reported that 200 Azerbaijani servicemen have been killed, the Azerbaijani Defense Ministry reported that 550 Armenians have been killed. Both, almost certainly, are clearly exaggerating, however the account can actually go to tons of of individuals, amongst whom the bulk will ultimately be, as in any struggle, civilians.

Meanwhile, each Baku and Yerevan have launched martial legislation. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan introduced a basic mobilization, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev – a partial mobilization. The combating continued on 28 September. What can occur subsequent if the battle drags on?

Will the battle in Nagorno-Karabakh flip right into a regional struggle?

There is a superb danger of a quite simple sequential growth of the battle: from bilateral to regional. Taking under consideration whose pursuits are already affected. First of all, that is Turkey. Ankara has already supported Azerbaijan in its confrontation with Armenia, saying the latter as the primary downside. Turkish journalists allegedly occurred to be on the website of the primary battles. On the eve of the outbreak of hostilities, joint workout routines of the Azerbaijani and Turkish navy passed off. The Armenian aspect claims that after the top of the maneuvers, the Turks didn’t go residence in any respect and at the moment are collaborating in hostilities.

There are additionally rumors concerning the switch of some pro-Turkish militants and mercenaries from Syria and even Libya. And such rumors aren’t new within the area. Back in 1993, a yr earlier than the peace settlement, they wrote that not solely Turkish volunteers, however even Afghan mujahideen have been combating alongside the Azerbaijanis. Then worldwide stress on Baku and Yerevan led to a brief diplomatic settlement of the battle, and it didn’t handle to turn into really worldwide.

On the opposite aspect is Russia. Armenia has already formally knowledgeable Moscow about what is going on – Pashinyan phoned Putin. The Armenian authorities turned to Greece for assist, straight calling to “curb” Turkey. By the way in which, it’s now in essentially the most acute battle in recent times, not solely with Armenia, however with its neighbors from the EU. And all due to the large deposits, which, based on Ankara, have been found by it on the backside of the Black and Mediterranean Seas, together with within the zone disputed with Cyprus. Moreover, the extraction of those minerals by Turkey can straight threaten the financial pursuits of Russia each on this nation and in southern Europe. In basic, there are sufficient conflicts within the area with out Karabakh.

Armenia, Russia, CSTO and USA

It needs to be remembered that Armenia is a member of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), and on its territory, in Gyumri, there’s a Russian navy base. Accordingly, when Azerbaijani commentators say that mobilization in Armenia is a cause for Azerbaijan to start out a struggle with it, they need to not overlook that the official declaration of struggle will give Yerevan the chance to show to its ally Russia for assist. And in Armenia they prefer to level out that the mom of Prime Minister Mikhail Mishustin is Armenian.

While the hostilities are formally going down on the territory of the self-proclaimed NKR, which Armenia itself didn’t acknowledge, formally, this doesn’t concern Moscow legally. But nobody is aware of precisely how Moscow will behave if the state of affairs modifications. The response of different influential international locations of the world can also be unknown.

For instance, the United States is in a pre-election fever till November, statements on the state of affairs in Nagorno-Karabakh are made by each President Donald Trump and his predominant rival Joe Biden. And, in all probability, the response of the Americans will likely be restricted to statements and stress by way of diplomatic channels. But if this isn’t a brand new, albeit extra highly effective, however nonetheless a take a look at of power, and sooner or later a full-fledged struggle, then nearly nobody can avoid the small Nagorno-Karabakh.

Author: Ivan Preobrazhensky – candidate of political sciences, professional on Central and Eastern Europe, columnist for quite a few media retailers. Author of a weekly column on DW. Ivan Preobrazhensky on Facebook: Ivan Preobrazhensky

The commentary expresses the private opinion of the creator. It could not coincide with the opinion of the Russian editorial workers and Deutsche Welle usually.

See additionally: